Development: 新人QBの早期起用、育成、評価に関する話題
現地3月19日、SNS上で、新人QBの早期起用、育成、評価を巡ってメディア関係者等の活発な意見交換がみられた。内容は以下のとおり。
参考資料
資料1: James Palmer (@JamesPalmerTV)の投稿より引用
As evaluations continue on the QBs in this draft ... of the 19 QBs drafted from 2021-2022, only 2 are expected to start in Week 1, 2024
— James Palmer (@JamesPalmerTV) March 19, 2024
- Trevor Lawrence the first pick in 2021
- Brock Purdy the last pick in 2022
資料2: Jason_OTC ( @Jason_OTC)の投稿より引用
The discussions around developing QBs is always an interesting topic. I think looking too far into the past is bad because the league is completely different as are the contracts of the players.
— Jason_OTC (@Jason_OTC) March 19, 2024
I do think one issue is that you can not really hide a developing QB anymore. The league is very QB centric now and bad play destroys a team. There are tons of veteran options at that point that teams feel safer with because of the downside of some of these younger players
— Jason_OTC (@Jason_OTC) March 19, 2024
I do think some coaches don't adjust great. Right now we are in a phase where the HC gets a job in large part because he lucked into coaching a Josh Allen and who knows what the coach can do with lesser QBs. Then presented the challenge of the lesser QB and its a problem
— Jason_OTC (@Jason_OTC) March 19, 2024
Part of the issue is teams jump on head coaches/offensive coordinators so quick now. Having success with 1 QB is one thing and may not be repeatable. Have they been functional with a few different style players? How did they adjust with others.
— Jason_OTC (@Jason_OTC) March 19, 2024
資料3: Bucky Brooks (@BuckyBrooks) の投稿より引用
The NFL has a QB evaluation and development problem. There’s no other way to spin it.. The league doesn’t know what leads to success at the position. And coaches do not know how to play around a QB’s flaws. Until those issues are fixed, we will continue to see a revolving door at… https://t.co/1pjTz7qRoH
— Bucky Brooks (@BuckyBrooks) March 19, 2024
資料4: Albert Breer (@AlbertBreer)の投稿より引用
Development pieces can't be fleshed out in 1 tweet, but ...
— Albert Breer (@AlbertBreer) March 19, 2024
1) Most QBs shouldn't start as rookies.
2) Guys playing too early get confidence crushed.
3) Being on a bad team—re: teams w/high picks—compounds the issue.
4) HC's job security can factor into play-time decisions. https://t.co/OT8p6oLa0n
資料5: Steven Ruiz (@theStevenRuiz)の投稿より引用
Allen, Mahomes, Lamar, Herbert, Burrow, Stroud, and Lawrence are all under 30. Not to mention others plus a good class coming in, which should give us at least one great QB.
— Steven Ruiz (@theStevenRuiz) March 19, 2024
I feel like the league is doing just fine? https://t.co/ICgCcuOIew
資料6: Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___)の投稿より引用
There are 32 starting spots and good QBs start until they're 35-40 years old now. The bar to replace an average-ish vet like Derek Carr is high.
— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) March 19, 2024
NFL teams aren't turning over starters at QB like other positions, but will continue to draft them hoping for an upside outcome https://t.co/kAHZoWVfZf
資料7: Eric Eager 📊🏈 (@ericeager_)の投稿より引用
first-round quarterbacks are too cheap via the 2011 CBA. Back when you had to pay top dollar to draft a quarterback in the top 10, you would hedge your bets with the Brad Johnsons and the Tony Romos on the end of the bench. Taking away the third QB was also short sighted. https://t.co/TGTJRYecHY
— Eric Eager 📊🏈 (@ericeager_) March 19, 2024
資料8: Eric Eager, sumersports.com, Should Rookie Quarterbacks Sit in Year One? (March 17, 2024)
Dan Pizzuta, Quarterback Drafting Dilemma: Bridging the College-to-NFL Gap