ウクライナ出身モデルがミス日本優勝。ミスコンのあり方はこれでいいのか？

This year, "Miss Japan" was won by a candidate whose parents are not Japanese but Ukrainian.  

＜英語記事＞

Ukrainian-born model winning Miss Japan re-ignites identity debate

＜日本語記事＞

ミス日本、グランプリにウクライナ出身モデル　「日本人のアイデンティティー」めぐる議論が再燃 - BBCニュース

※本記事は椎野カロリーナさんご自身やミス日本への出場を否定するものではありません。ミスコンのあり方そのものを議題として取り扱うことだけを意図としています。

This has caused a debate in public. Some people argue that her winning symbolizes how internationalized Japan is while others point out that the competition was conducted appropriately as "Miss Japan". Now, let's take a look at how people are reacting about this situation.

Pros:

1. Reflecting Modern Japan: Embracing a Miss Japan with diverse heritage reflects the multicultural reality of modern Japan. Japan is becoming increasingly diverse, and the inclusion of contestants from different backgrounds is a positive step towards acknowledging and celebrating this diversity.

2. Global Perspective: Allowing contestants with diverse backgrounds can offer a more global perspective. It not only opens up opportunities for international collaboration but also promotes a positive image of Japan as an inclusive and welcoming society on the world stage.

3. Breaking Stereotypes: The inclusion of a winner with non-Japanese parents challenges traditional stereotypes about what it means to be Japanese. This can inspire a broader acceptance of diverse identities and contribute to breaking down cultural barriers.

Cons:

1. Cultural Appropriation Concerns: Some argue that having a winner with non-Japanese roots might lead to concerns about cultural appropriation. Critics fear that contestants might not fully understand or appreciate the cultural nuances and significance attached to being Japanese.

2. Questioning Authenticity: Traditionalists may question the authenticity of the Miss Japan contest if the winner does not have a direct Japanese lineage. They may argue that the competition should prioritize preserving and showcasing the unique beauty and culture of Japan.

3. Potential Backlash: The decision to crown a winner with non-Japanese parents may face backlash from those who believe that the Miss Japan contest should exclusively represent individuals with a Japanese heritage. This could lead to divisiveness within the community.

As described above, this situation is not quite straightforward. Essentially, we Japanese people are questioned if we are willing to accept the flow of era or stick with the tradition. Now, the debate question asks you, "should "Miss Japan contest" be held with more restrictions for candidates?"

Please note, we assume that the current regulation only requires candidates to have Japanese nationality.