憲法1 /Constitution1-ver0

#憲法 #Constitution #Chibil

1. How many countries have constitutions?

• 192 out of 195 recognized sovereign states have formal constitutions (2023 data).

  • United Kingdom: No single written constitution, governed by statutes and conventions such as the Magna Carta (1215) and Bill of Rights (1689).

  • New Zealand: No codified constitution; its framework consists of Constitution Act (1986) and previous laws like the Treaty of Waitangi (1840).

  • Israel: Operates under Basic Laws (since 1950), which function as an evolving constitutional framework​

2.What types of constitutions are there?

• Written Constitutions:

  • United States (1789): Oldest active written constitution with a rigid amendment process.

  • India (1950): Longest constitution in the world, reflecting the country's diverse cultural and legal heritage.

• Unwritten Constitutions:

  • United Kingdom: Relies on legal documents like Magna Carta (1215) and statutes such as the Bill of Rights (1689).

  • New Zealand: Governed by statutes such as the Constitution Act (1986) and key legal precedents.

• Rigid Constitutions:

  • Japan (1947): Has never been amended due to a complex amendment process requiring a two-thirds majority and a national referendum.

  • United States (1789): Requires a difficult amendment process involving Congress and states, leading to very few amendments.

• Flexible Constitutions:

  • Denmark (1953): Allows easier amendments through legislative processes without needing supermajority votes.

  • New Zealand: Flexible due to its reliance on ordinary statutes, allowing for easier legal reforms

3. How is Japan’s Constitution similar to or different from others?

• Similarities:

  • Germany (1949): Focuses on democracy, human rights, and parliamentary governance, much like Japan’s post-WWII constitution.

  • Italy (1948): Emphasizes democratic principles and human rights, similar to Japan’s constitution adopted after WWII under Allied supervision.

• Differences:

  • Japan (1947): Article 9 renounces war and prohibits the country from maintaining armed forces for warfare, a unique clause compared to most nations.

  • Costa Rica (1949): Abolished its military, but unlike Japan, this was done voluntarily rather than imposed externally. Costa Rica’s military abolition was also more flexible in practice.

• Amendment Processes:

  • France (1958): Has been amended multiple times, showing greater flexibility compared to Japan’s rigid amendment procedures​

4. Are there trends in constitutions?

• Past Trends (Post-WWII to 1990s):

  • Germany (1949): Adopted after WWII to establish democracy and prevent authoritarianism.

  • India (1950): Adopted post-colonial independence, focusing on national sovereignty, human rights, and equality.

• Present Trends (1990s to Today):

  • Ecuador (2008): Includes provisions for environmental rights, recognizing nature as having legal standing, reflecting a modern emphasis on sustainability.

  • Croatia (1991): Adopted after the dissolution of Yugoslavia, with a focus on democratic governance and human rights as it transitioned to European Union membership.

• Future Trends:

  • Chile (2021): Drafting a new constitution with a strong emphasis on environmental protections and indigenous rights, likely to become a trend in future constitutional reforms worldwide.

  • Tunisia (2014): The new constitution addresses issues like gender equality and democratic governance after the Arab Spring, reflecting the growing trend of constitutions addressing justice issues​.

---

Reference

• World Population Review
  Data on the number of countries with constitutions, including written and unwritten constitutions:
  Countries with Constitutions 2024​

• Wikipedia - List of National Constitutions
  Provides historical context and detailed examples of constitutions from different countries, including their adoption dates:
  List of National Constitutions - Wikipedia​

• Comparative Constitutions Project
  Timeline and detailed descriptions of constitutions from around the world, including specific country examples and constitutional trends:
  Comparative Constitutions Project​

• ConstitutionNet
  Analysis of trends in constitution-making, including recent changes and focus on environmental, gender, and indigenous rights in new constitutional frameworks:
  ConstitutionNet - World of Constitution Building​